Showing posts with label education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label education. Show all posts

Thursday, November 4, 2010

We Need To Stress Fundamentals Again In Education

When I went to school, the philosophy was to teach the "3 R's," reading, 'riting and 'rithmetic. Having come into contact many college students and even graduates, I have found that many exhibit poor writing skills. When I have interviewed young people, and requested three paragraphs from them as part of the process, the result has convinced me that today's educational system has not sufficiently emphasized this aspect. While certain new developments and advances have furthered educated, this de-emphasis in necessary skills has been detrimental to our future generations.

Many of these young people are otherwise extremely bright and talented, so the lack of writing skills cannot be attributed to a any lack of intellect, or intelligence. My conclusion is that when schools and school "policy makers" decided years ago that other things were more important to teach than the "3 R's," they de-emphasized formal writing skills. Many of the same young people who have difficulty writing, have an incredible grasp of concepts, and an otherwise superb skill- set. However, it appears that many schools have maintained emphasis on only one of the "R's," reading, while placing far less emphasis on either writing or arithmetic. Many of the young people who exhibit writing challenges also have far less mastery of basic mathematical skills, such as addition, multiplication, subtraction and division. These individuals have been taught many sophisticated ideas and concepts mathematically, but a large number must depend on a calculator or some other device to do even the most basic of mathematical functions.

Have there been some benefits to today's students because of this change of emphasis? There certainly have been in the areas of technology, technology usage, interpretation, music and the arts. However, where I believe the system has "let down" these "kids" is in mastering many basic skills. In the attempt to educationally "reinvent the wheel," and correct some of the "malfunctions" of previous educational policy (such as teaching by rote, memorization, and not relating what was being taught to practical usage), the "new education" causes huge gaps in necessary skills. For example, if someone cannot adequately put thoughts to paper, how is one able to express himself to others? Today's over-dependence on such things as "texting language," has created a generation weak in grammatical skills, spelling ability, and vocabulary. The "abbreviations" used instead of words, the shortcuts, etc., are fine when using SMS or MMS media, but are not the optimum way to communicate in a regular written document, either on paper, in a Web- article, in a well- written Blog, etc.

Hopefully, educators will realize that written and basic mathematical skills are a necessary learning block that must be taught, used and mastered, if more sophisticated ideas are to be optimally learned. Educators must also learn that while the "3 R's" may not be "fun," they are necessary in the real world of everyday life and business. Many colleges and universities have realized the lack of these skills in their students, and have begun to emphasize important skills, such as writing. However, isn't it somewhat unfair to college students to have to shoulder addition stress and burden to have to first master these skills in college (often extending the length of time it takes to graduate, plus the additional expense), when the basics should have been adequately taught prior to that. One of the reasons that the SAT exams now has a written component is because of the recognition of writing as a necessary and essential skill.

Parents should emphasize these needs to their School Boards when children are younger, so that college students are far better prepared. Parents should do this from both an educational as well as financial point of view . Does anyone really believe that this educational deficiency and the fact that most students average five or more years to finish college today, are unrelated? Let's get back to some basics, so that students will be better equipped to handle life's challenges and needs!


Tuesday, November 10, 2009

The Long Island School Tax Dilemna

Since school taxes account for 60% or more of the real estate taxes in Long Island, and that ever-growing burden has been widely recognized, it is deeply disconcerting when Newsday this morning ran an article about how there was a wide disparity between the projected school tax for this year (projected when budgets were voted on) and the actual tax rate recently implemented. School districts like Roslyn, which projected tax increases below 2% are now actually imposing taxes greater than 4.5%. Across Long Island, the actual tax being imposed is substantially greater than the projections.
Several reasons have been cited, including: commercial tax assessment reduction resulting in a lower than anticipated tax collection; previous residential tax assessment appeals that lowered tax collections, etc. Whether that is the complete reason, or it is also a matter of "political spin," where school budget proponents use a favorable estimate when they are campaigning for the budget; or the overall economic crisis; or lower than anticipated grants received - - it turns out that homeowners end up paying for the miscalculation.
That being said, the real issues are the way our schools are paid for; the efficiencies or lack of efficiencies built into the present system; state and federal unfunded mandates. And though, lots of people complain about the costs, the debate always becomes a polarizing one between parents who say, "The children deserve the best," and stressed-out homeowners, who say, "It costs too much . . . cut . . . cut!" Yet neither side kis fully
examining all options. I truly believe it is NOT a matter of how much it costs to run schools, but how the money is spent! What efficiencies are schools not using that could save substantial monies while not having any adverse educational effect. Because it has never been demonstrated that educational quality is simply a matter of how much money is spent! For example, in New York City, there has been some evidence that the use of privately run Charter Schools create better educations, often at lower costs. Here on Long Island, for example, schools use varying class period lengths, ranging from 40 minutes to one hour. Most educational studies have indicated that the shorter periods create more effective learning because of attention spans. In addition, because of the way many teacher contracts are structured, the one-hour length creates an inability to get as many classroom hours per teacher, thus requiring hiring more teachers. Some high schools on Long Island use the One Principal/ One Asst Principal plus deans model, while others use the Principal, Asst Principal for every grade model, which obviously is a costlier model. Yet each model has its proponents.
On Long Island, different school districts range in size, yet each hires a Superintendent and staff, so therefore the larger districts enjoy economies of scale, and thus lower costs per students.
Similarly, there are potential savings if districts would use more centralized purchasing. In Nassau County, some school districts utilize BOCES to create better economies, but there are many more savings. For example, joint negotiating for buses, etc., would create savings for most districts.
Homeowners must demand accountability, or they give up their "right to complain." The methodology of voting for school budgets, where defeating a budget creates an automatic contingency budget, which saves little money but mandates how the money is spent, often creates an even worse alternative. We deserve better, and must demand a better, more streamlined, more effective and efficient system, which better educates and prepares our children.
Enough of being told, "We do it this way because that's how we've always done it." It's time to think outside the box!